Sunday, July 19, 2009

How we ended up here.....

Below are the link to a few blog posts that you might find of interest. One of the most fascinating aspects of the summer read selection "The Book of Learning and Forgetting" by Frank Smith is the history of education. How we ended up with our current industrial model is a story that too often goes untold.

Ira Socol is a PhD student at Michigan State and a respected researcher in the area of the history of education. These are two posts worth a read.

Counting the Origins of Failure

and


Today's School Reformers vs. Real Change for Education

Give them a look and leave a comment below

Wednesday, July 8, 2009

Charter Schools and Us

I've been asked recently what I think of the new proposal for a charter school in Peoria IL. Charters are public schools usually operated by a private company or entity. This entity is often a for profit business but can also be a non profit group. The goal of the Peoria Charter school is to create a junior high focused on math and science courses and job skill creation.

First I don't think we should feel threatened by such a school. As a Catholic school we are mission driven. Our purpose is focuses on providing our graduates with a thorough understanding of the Christian world view to enable them to live grace filled lives. Our mission statement pays respect to these goals. Put shortly we advance the Gospel. A primary reason for choosing PND on the part of our families should be this mission. Everything else is secondary to the mission.

Any school that engages children and helps them become life long learners and productive citizens is a good idea. Is this charter school such a school? I imagine time will tell. I worry that often such charter's become a place to avoid what are considered to be the problems of traditional public schools. Too often those with position and power manipulate the system to gain entrance to these schools while those who are in most need of such a great education go without. So a big question I have is who will be admitted? Does it matter who you know? Does it matter who mommy and daddy are? A critical reader might argue PND is only for the rich. I'd beg to differ. We need to be an elite (doing what we do well) school without being elitist. We need to always push ourselves in making financial assistance available and being able to keep the door open for those who desire a Catholic education. We need to do a better job of all of this and we will.

I worry about vocational schools. There seems to be a heavy emphasis on job skills with this charter. Whatever happened to employers doing their own employee training? Do public schools exist just to create workers? What about forming the whole person. Catholic schools aim to develop the whole person: body, mind, and soul. I'd argue that a well developed human being , with acquired virtues, and a moral compass will have what it takes to be a productive employee. In fact they might even be a productive human being who raises a family and live lives filled with love and service to each other. In the end a paycheck is paycheck and life is more than title and pay.

Just some thoughts I'd love to hear yours. A blog I follow has some great articles on charters. I wish the group founding this school well and that their noble intentions are followed up with equally noble actions and operation.