Wednesday, February 20, 2008

To Track or not to Track?

Why do we track?  Is it in the best interest of our students?  Do we reflect on why we do it?  Should we just track for honors?  Are our students in modified classes better served by being placed in regular settings and being asked to live up the expectations of the regular classroom?  The answers to these questions hit at the core of our philosophy of learning.  Do we see every student as able to learn, create, and grow in understanding?  Or, do we fall victim of pre-judging students' ability based on their standardized test scores which have placed them in a modified section?

Would Notre Dame be better served by placing modified students in regular classrooms?  Would this lead to fewer behavior problems?  Would teaching strategies have to be adopted and changed if this were to happen i.e. differentiated instruction?  What does the research say?  
There are pros and cons to both routes.  One could argue de-tracking the modified sections would disperse the modified students evenly into various sections forcing these students to work towards the higher norm of performance in the regular setting.  Behavior problems would decrease as students in modified sections are surrounded by different students in each period.  

De-tracking honors would most likely be a disaster with students leaving in droves for the IB program and other accelerated programs.  

Below is a link to some research on the subject.  If anyone has hear of or can find links to other studies about the tracking issue please post the link as well.    Let the conversation start. 


12 comments:

Ms. P. said...

It has been my experience in teaching modified students that they feel more comfortable in a learning environment that does not "make them feel stupid."


In a modified classroom, they can find a degree of success that would be otherwise impossible in a regular classroom...not because they won't do the work, but because they feel that they are always struggling to keep their heads above water.

JulSki410 said...

Well, my intitial gut reaction is without modified - how would we best serve students with legitimate learning challenges. We already provide minimal accomodations to students with IEP's - some of them really need the differing structure, pace and smaller class size that are supposed to be offered in our modified classes. There is no reason modified classes cannot be challenging - just in a different approach.

I think we need to be careful not to make generalizations that students in modified classes as behavior problems. Just the way things go, perhaps students who are behavior problems just end up in modified classes. If this is the case - won't they be behavior problems in "regular" classes too? Peer pressure is powerful - but the small number of students we are referring to here are probably not going to respond to the positive peer pressure in "regular" classes either...

still thinking about this though...

Charlie Roy said...

When you read through the attached link it is clear that the research is often mixed on the topic. Many education advocates that students are short changed in modified classes where as when placed in a regular setting they more often than not work up to a higher level of performance. Placing students in a regular classroom where differentied instruction is practiced can sometimes be the best strategy.

One question that might need to be asked is about our strategy for placing students in modified sections. Should we do this by low range test scores or should only students with Section 504 plans be made eligible for modified placement?

Do we need to only track in only a few subjects?

Would eliminating modified classes make scheduling more efficient?

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Charlie Roy said...

Please remember that according to the rules of the blog rule #1 anonymous posts are not allowed on the blog.

Anonymous said...

If we do eliminate modified, then I think we need a resource room staffed with a special ed teacher to address students whose lack of success is due to a disability other than the lack of desire.

Anonymous said...

Many schools do just that. The track only between honors and regular and then provide a help room staffed by teachers with speical education training. The credits are sometimes lowered a bit in terms of graduation requirments to provide more pull out time.

Anonymous said...

that was me above

Ms. P. said...

We would need greater control of the student population in the resource room. Now, it seems parents/students sign up for modified classes at will...some have documentation, some don't. To really help the students who qualify for the resource room, we would have to really tighten the requirements for that program. I could see those qualified students needing to be in resource for more than one class period a day; however, the number of students in the room at a time MUST remain low.

JulSki410 said...

For clarification... I can only speak for the last 2 years, but in general students/parents don't really "sign up" for modified and the student does not have to have an IEP for them to be placed in modified. As incoming freshman, they are placed in modified based on standardized test results - previously the Terra Nova or ISATs, and more recently the EXPLORE. Placement in subsequent years is dependent on the grade earned in current coursework. Parents can always opt I suppose to place their child in a "lower" level than where they were placed, but I personally don't see a lot of parents asking for modified when it wasn't recommended by testing results.

I don't think modified is necessarily the same concept as resource, is it? Modified is a different pace and structure to help students who learn differently, whether they have an IEP or not. Resource is for students with an IEP - no? And we have some students with IEPs who do just fine in "regular" classes with some simple accomodations. And we have some students without IEPs who crash and burn in regular - and modified - classes.

No, Charlie, I haven't read the article yet. I will soon...

Anonymous said...

We must continue tracking our students. Since we are stressing "being customer friendly," do we want to set up the less-skilled learner to fail? In the modified classes, the same maerial is taught, but in a slower, less in-depth manner. The students have more guided practice, more note taking and a re given tests and quizzes that they can demonstrate the skills they have learned. Would a modified students be successful in a regular class? Possible, but at alower level. These students wouod be earning grades of D's and F's, rather than the higher grades in the modified class. I do not suggest that every modified student is earning high grades (Lord knows there are students in the modified class that won't turn in work), but the chance for success for this student is very real. Keep on tracking.

Anonymous said...

I think the student might fail if they are placed in a regular classroom and the teacher keeps on teaching with the same style they are used to. Differentiated Instruction means adjusting the teaching strategy to the learning style of the learner.

If we are just going to "sage on the stage" and worksheet the student to death there probably won't be much progress. Students might be more apt to turn in assignments as this is the norm in the regular classroom. It would be fascinating to analyze the data from blackbaud and see what the rate of missing homework is by tracking level. Maybe there is no difference.

But then again if we understand and utilize varied instructional strategies such as providing choice in assignments and other tools it could have great success to restructure to a resource style pull out.

Deciding who would get the pull-outs is of course open for debate. Not every student who has an IEP requires a modified placement or pull-outs.