
We'll as predicted Facebook and its improper use has become a little bit of an issue as we move into our 1:1 computing environment. Let's give it some thought.
First the ongoing issue in any school environment is engagement. Engaged students learn more and misbehave less. Good teaching leads to high levels of engagement and poor teaching leads in general to boredom and the host of issues that are attached to it. Students for years have found ways to disengage from doodling on their desk to passing notes. The issue is not the lack of complete focus but rather the new medium. Talking in class is fundamentally no different than sending a friend a message on Facebook during class. The problem is engagement the medium is rather irrelevant.
So where are we at with FB and appropriate vs. inappropriate use at school. We'll the tech guys have been crunching the numbers and low and behold some students have been on FB during class time. Surprised? The fun part is of course I've gotten a few emails about and rightfully so. My favorite one was the call from a gal at work who saw her daughter posted to FB during class. I asked her how she knew and she said she saw it on FB at work. I asked if her boss knew she looked at FB during work and the line went eerily silent.
Well anyway in an ideal world we could count on our students to avoid FB in class and only use it before school, after school, and during advisory. But alas we don't have a perfect world. But maybe just maybe our students don't understand that we know they are on FB at inappropriate times. So the way I see it we have five options.
1. Who cares: This option involves saying if you zone out you zone out and your only hurting yourself so enjoy the rewards of your labor and enjoy repeating your classes. But then again part of having a 1:1 environment is to boost our academic achievement so this doesn't seem like the best of all plans.
2. Warn them and Move on: Perhaps step one should be an initial warning. We could treat our students with dignity remind them of their obligation to work hard and focus on their learning and see if that solves it. Maybe it will maybe it won't. Time will tell. We can always deal with the super offenders on an individual basis.
3. Block FB during school except before school after school and during advisory: Pretty simple on this one and barracuda allows it to be done. The only downside would be in some classes a creative teacher can actually come up with creative educational uses for FB.
4. Block FB all the time: We'll this is a fun idea. Sounds kind of draconian but hey most work places seem to do this so why not. But then what else do we block? Of course we block the evil sites but where would this lead?
5. Facebook Detention: You heard it right. We can actually track usage individually and then just block offenders out for a long period of time. It's a nice natural consequence but a managerial pain. But then again it would be differentiated instruction. Kind of.
Anyway we'll be taking the issue up during the house leader meeting this week. We'll let you know the route we'll go. We might gather some feedback. Leave your comments below.
4 comments:
Charlie, an interesting list of avenues for us to explore as a learning environment.
I have found in my classes that it's not the occasional status update to FB that is the issue...it's the video chatting through SKYPE, OOVOO, and the like. For more info on SKYPE & OOVOO: http://www.crazyadventuresinparenting.com/2009/02/oovoo-vs-skype-which-is-better-for-you.html
Interestingly, I have found their use of FB to be mostly in the chat function. Talking in class, as you mentioned, is taking on a new "voice." Their faces give it all away...you don't even have to use LAN Shark to see what they are doing. I have noticed that the students who are focused and do their work first are done well before the ones who are constantly disturbed by ongoing and annoying chat interruptions. I would much rather have them zoned into their own music in iTunes and focused than I would interrupting each other during productive work time with annoy chat comments.
You could have teachers base some of the students' grades in participation. Those who are good students who are not on FB all the time are rewarded for participation (listening, not being distracted, giving their opinions in class, etc). They do this in college a great deal. After seeing their grades, the FB users will see (or should see) that they are suffering in school directly because of their FB use and should discontinue it.
Another way you could discourage FB use is by putting a phrase (like "excessively on Facebook during class") in their report cards similar to the way teachers put "Great overall effort" on them. This will let their parents see what they are doing, and for the most part, reprimand them. I mean I would if I were them, paying the money they do for both the computer and the education.
The easiest way would probably be blocking FB during school. If there happen to be teachers who can make FB educational, they will be so creative that they could find other sites that are educational. The students probably won't be happy about it, but they aren't the ones paying for the great education.
Just some ideas!! Ms. P and Mr. Roy, you guys are great!! Keep up the good work!
I've caught more kids on Skype than FB. By the way, one or two have been kids who forgot to log out of my LanSchool channel, and I find them doing it in someone else's class. I send them a "force student to read this message" message and tell them to log out of my channel. They know I saw what they were doing.
I do give participation points and deduct for off-task behavior.
I think if you put a comment about FB on the report card, you're going to get a barrage of angry parents wondering why we allow it in the first place. I think that testing out our current policy for a couple of weeks and revisiting the matter is the best choice right now.
I go back and forth. There certainly is the potential for the malaise to come about if we put all this effort and energy into a productive learning community with "active learning" being enabled by the macbooks. If it devolves into the majority of the students staring aimlessly at FB alas that would not be the desired outcome. One of the constant standards for national board certification is the importance of video taping yourself teaching. One of the most common experiences in this process has been to observe just how off task so many students are.
So in some ways the problem is the same problem again and again and that is a lack of engagement. Instead of passing notes students type a chat on skype or FB. Skype has powerful learning applications that as time goes on more and more instructors will recognize.
The point of using the technology is not to automate passive pedagogy but to enable active engaged pedagogical approaches to take hold. It takes time but it takes a shift in thinking to make it happen.
Post a Comment